Ocean Prime offers an exceptional fine-dining experience. Known for its sophisticated atmosphere, the menu features high-quality seafood and premium steaks. It is the perfect destination for special occasions and business dinners.
Best Seafood Restaurants in Indianapolis Indiana - June 2026
USA / Indiana / Indianapolis
Discover the finest seafood dining experiences in Indianapolis. From fresh oyster bars to upscale nautical-themed bistros, explore our curated list of top-rated spots for the perfect catch.
Upscale seafood and steakhouse with a vibrant atmosphere.
Details
- Year Founded: 2006
- Employees: 200-500
- Price Range: $$$$
- Phone: +13179721340
- Email: info@ocean-prime.com
About the Company
Pros
- Exquisite service
- Prime downtown location
Cons
- High price point
- Requires reservation
Authentic seafood market and restaurant experience.
Details
- Year Founded: 2018
- Employees: 50-100
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +13175368600
- Email: contact@pier48fishhouse.com
About the Company
Pier 48 brings the coastal fish house vibe to the heart of Indianapolis. They excel in fresh oysters and daily-caught fish selections, prepared with a modern culinary twist in a relaxed, industrial-chic setting.
Pros
- Fresh oyster variety
- Great happy hour
Cons
- Limited parking
- Can get very loud
Fine dining seafood institution known for quality.
Details
- Year Founded: 1998
- Employees: 100-200
- Price Range: $$$$
- Phone: +13179552274
- Email: indy@theoceanaire.com
About the Company
An upscale destination for seafood lovers, The Oceanaire specializes in daily fresh catches flown in from around the globe. The service is impeccable, and the wine list is curated to pair perfectly with their exquisite fish dishes.
Pros
- Extensive seafood selection
- Professional staff
Cons
- Expensive
- Formal dress code preferred
Classic upscale steakhouse with premier seafood.
Details
- Year Founded: 1990
- Employees: 500+
- Price Range: $$$$
- Phone: +13174238790
- Email: info@capitalgrille.com
About the Company
While known for steaks, their seafood offerings are top-tier. From Chilean sea bass to fresh lobster, the quality control is excellent. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a staple for high-end dining in Indy.
Pros
- Excellent atmosphere
- Top-tier seafood
Cons
- Steak-focused menu
- Strictly upscale
Classic seafood menu with daily fresh sheet.
Details
- Year Founded: 1974
- Employees: 500+
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +13176319500
- Email: service@ms-sf.com
About the Company
McCormick & Schmick's remains a reliable choice for traditional seafood. Their "fresh sheet" is updated daily, ensuring the catch of the day is always fresh. A great spot for a comfortable, reliable seafood dinner.
Pros
- Consistent quality
- Great variety
Cons
- Older decor
- Can be crowded
Wood-fired seafood and prime steaks.
Details
- Year Founded: 2002
- Employees: 100-200
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +13175699990
- Email: contact@jgilberts.com
About the Company
J. Gilbert's combines wood-fired grilling with high-quality seafood. Their unique cooking method brings out intense flavors in their fish dishes, making them stand out in the local Indianapolis dining scene.
Pros
- Unique wood-fire flavor
- Cozy ambiance
Cons
- Located slightly outside center
- Limited menu items
Luxurious seafood dining with live jazz.
Details
- Year Founded: 2000
- Employees: 200-500
- Price Range: $$$$
- Phone: +13174233777
- Email: info@eddiev.com
About the Company
Eddie V's offers a premium experience where fresh seafood meets live jazz. The ambiance is elegant and the menu is perfectly executed, catering to those who appreciate a refined, high-energy dining atmosphere.
Pros
- Live jazz music
- Top-tier service
Cons
- Very expensive
- Requires advance booking
Modern creative dishes with daily fish features.
Details
- Year Founded: 2012
- Employees: 20-50
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +13176861580
- Email: hello@bluebeardindy.com
About the Company
While not strictly a seafood restaurant, Bluebeard's creative approach to market-fresh ingredients ensures their fish dishes are always stellar. A trendy, locally loved spot in the Holy Rosary neighborhood.
Pros
- Creative menu
- Local atmosphere
Cons
- Menu changes often
- Small portion sizes
Upscale dining featuring high-quality seafood.
Details
- Year Founded: 2007
- Employees: 100-300
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +13176359594
- Email: info@harryandizzys.com
About the Company
Sister restaurant to St. Elmo, Harry & Izzy's offers a more relaxed but equally high-quality menu. Their seafood selection is fresh and prepared with a focus on classic flavors that delight every guest.
Pros
- Classic Indy vibe
- Great shrimp cocktail
Cons
- Can be noisy
- Busy location
Known for Brazilian steak, but features excellent seafood.
Details
- Year Founded: 1979
- Employees: 500+
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +13176384000
- Email: support@fogo.com
About the Company
Though a steakhouse, their seafood buffet options and a la carte sea bass are remarkably fresh. Perfect for groups looking for a wide variety of high-quality proteins in an upscale downtown setting.
Pros
- Wide variety
- Unlimited options
Cons
- Heavy meat focus
- Expensive buffet
Casual, fresh seafood chain.
Details
- Year Founded: 2000
- Employees: 500+
- Price Range: $$
- Phone: +13175713474
- Email: contact@bonefishgrill.com
About the Company
A dependable and approachable spot for fresh fish. Bonefish Grill focuses on wood-grilled specialties and excellent appetizers like their famous Bang Bang Shrimp. A great family-friendly choice.
Pros
- Affordable
- Consistent quality
Cons
- Chain environment
- Casual dining only
Seafood-forward eatery on Massachusetts Ave.
Details
- Year Founded: 2015
- Employees: 20-50
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +13176343100
- Email: info@saltonmass.com
About the Company
Located on the vibrant Mass Ave, Salt offers a fresh take on modern seafood dishes. The menu features seasonal ingredients, making it a great place to enjoy innovative flavors in an urban setting.
Pros
- Prime location
- Innovative menu
Cons
- Limited street parking
- Small dining area
Upscale chophouse with fresh ocean catches.
Details
- Year Founded: 2018
- Employees: 50-100
- Price Range: $$$$
- Phone: +13178484848
- Email: events@anthonyschophouse.com
About the Company
Anthony's delivers a high-end dining experience with exceptional seafood selections. Their commitment to quality and service makes it a standout choice for an elegant evening out in the area.
Pros
- Stunning views
- Top-tier service
Cons
- Very high price
- Requires reservations
Known for artisan food with fish options.
Details
- Year Founded: 2016
- Employees: 10-30
- Price Range: $$
- Phone: +13174931887
- Email: contact@leviathanbakehouse.com
About the Company
While known for their incredible baked goods, their menu features artisan-quality seafood sandwiches and lunch options. Perfect for a lighter, high-quality seafood meal during the day.
Pros
- Fresh ingredients
- Unique lunch items
Cons
- Limited hours
- Casual counter service
Farm-to-table focus with seasonal fish.
Details
- Year Founded: 2014
- Employees: 20-50
- Price Range: $$
- Phone: +13179640865
- Email: info@publicgreens.com
About the Company
A unique farm-to-table concept that highlights local produce alongside sustainably sourced fish. Their menu changes seasonally, ensuring every seafood dish is as fresh as the farm vegetables served alongside.
Pros
- Locally sourced
- Sustainable focus
Cons
- Very casual
- Limited menu variety
Are you listed here?
Choose your badge style and add it to your website.
Preview
📋 Your Embed Code
Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I find the freshest seafood in Indianapolis?
A: Indianapolis offers several high-end restaurants that import fresh seafood daily from coastal regions.
Q: Are there casual seafood dining options in Indianapolis?
A: Yes, there are many casual eateries and oyster bars perfect for a relaxed meal.
Q: Do these restaurants offer outdoor seating?
A: Many of the top-rated seafood spots in the city feature beautiful outdoor patios for summer dining.
Q: Is a reservation necessary for seafood restaurants in Indy?
A: It is highly recommended to book a table in advance, especially for popular fine-dining seafood establishments.
Q: What types of dishes can I expect?
A: You can find everything from classic lobster rolls and clam chowder to sophisticated seared scallops and fresh sushi.
Q: Are there kid-friendly seafood options in the city?
A: Many local seafood restaurants offer family-friendly menus that cater to various tastes.