Rich & Cartmill offers a broad spectrum of insurance solutions with a focus on risk management. Their team provides tailored advice for commercial clients, ensuring robust coverage options and personalized support throughout the policy lifecycle.
Best Insurance Brokers in Oklahoma City - June 2026
USA / Oklahoma / Oklahoma City
Discover the most reliable and highly-rated insurance brokers in Oklahoma City. We provide expert guidance to help you find the best coverage for your personal and business needs.
Comprehensive insurance brokerage services for businesses and individuals.
Details
- Year Founded: 1922
- Employees: 200-500
- Price Range: $$$$
- Phone: +14052326151
- Email: info@rcins.com
About the Company
Pros
- Expert risk management
- Strong industry reputation
Cons
- Higher premiums
- Limited online portal features
A trusted independent insurance agency providing customized coverage.
Details
- Year Founded: 1965
- Employees: 11-50
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +14058482488
- Email: contact@hagginwimberly.com
About the Company
Specializing in property, casualty, and commercial insurance, Haggin-Wimberly provides a highly professional approach to risk assessment. Their brokers are noted for deep market knowledge and consistent communication.
Pros
- Customized policy design
- Responsive account management
Cons
- Smaller agency size
- Limited office hours
Full-service insurance agency dedicated to client satisfaction.
Details
- Year Founded: 1980
- Employees: 50-100
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +14059438000
- Email: service@ica-ok.com
About the Company
Insurance Center Agency is well-regarded for its extensive portfolio of personal and business insurance products. Their brokers emphasize clear explanations of complex policy details, ensuring clients are well-protected.
Pros
- Great customer service
- Wide carrier options
Cons
- Occasional delays in renewals
- Complex website navigation
Integrated financial and insurance brokerage solutions.
Details
- Year Founded: 1910
- Employees: 500+
- Price Range: $$$$
- Phone: +14052722000
- Email: info@bokf.com
About the Company
Leveraging a major financial institution's backing, this group provides high-level risk management services for businesses. Ideal for corporations seeking integrated coverage and long-term financial planning.
Pros
- Corporate financial backing
- Access to diverse markets
Cons
- Strict qualification process
- Less personal touch
Reliable insurance brokerage serving the local community.
Details
- Year Founded: 1995
- Employees: 1-10
- Price Range: $$
- Phone: +14056012800
- Email: sales@okc-ins.com
About the Company
OKC Insurance Agency provides accessible and straightforward insurance options. They are known for simplifying the brokerage process for small businesses and families, providing efficient service.
Pros
- Local expertise
- Fast claims assistance
Cons
- Limited product variety
- Standard support hours
Professional brokers focused on property and liability coverage.
Details
- Year Founded: 1978
- Employees: 20-50
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +14057891234
- Email: hello@firstins.com
About the Company
First Insurance Brokers maintains a strong focus on technical expertise. Their consultants help businesses identify hidden risks, providing highly efficient solutions for competitive coverage premiums.
Pros
- Technical risk analysis
- Strong relationships with carriers
Cons
- Conservative approach
- Long onboarding time
Elevated service standards for business insurance brokerage.
Details
- Year Founded: 2005
- Employees: 10-25
- Price Range: $$$$
- Phone: +14055559876
- Email: info@summitok.com
About the Company
Summit Insurance Services prides itself on proactive client communication. They go beyond standard brokerage services, offering regular policy audits to ensure coverage matches business growth and changes.
Pros
- Proactive service
- Annual coverage reviews
Cons
- Premium price points
- Busy wait times
Specialized insurance brokers for industrial and commercial clients.
Details
- Year Founded: 1990
- Employees: 30-60
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +14052345678
- Email: contact@metrook.com
About the Company
Metro Brokers provides deep insight into specialized industrial sectors. Their ability to negotiate complex risk packages makes them a top choice for firms with unique operational hazards in Oklahoma City.
Pros
- Industry-specific expertise
- Strong negotiation skills
Cons
- Less focus on individual clients
- Formal structure
Comprehensive brokerage offering peace of mind through strategy.
Details
- Year Founded: 1988
- Employees: 15-40
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +14054443333
- Email: services@premierok.com
About the Company
Premier Oklahoma Insurance combines traditional values with modern brokerage tools. They focus on building long-term relationships through transparency and detailed reporting on insurance programs.
Pros
- Transparent communication
- Holistic strategy
Cons
- Heavy documentation
- Slow email response
High-end brokerage focusing on customized commercial plans.
Details
- Year Founded: 2012
- Employees: 5-15
- Price Range: $$$$$
- Phone: +14057778888
- Email: team@elite-okc.com
About the Company
Elite provides a highly curated insurance shopping experience. Their strength lies in their ability to synthesize multiple policies into a cohesive program for high-net-worth individuals and businesses.
Pros
- Exclusive market access
- Bespoke planning
Cons
- Only for high-volume clients
- High service fees
An independent agency focused on business risk management.
Details
- Year Founded: 2001
- Employees: 10-30
- Price Range: $$
- Phone: +14053334444
- Email: info@libertyok.com
About the Company
Liberty Insurance Partners excels in tailoring liability packages. Their team is dedicated to staying updated on regulatory changes, ensuring their clients remain compliant while reducing exposure risks.
Pros
- Compliance knowledge
- Reliable partner
Cons
- Limited online features
- Basic service model
Long-standing brokerage firm with a focus on deep analysis.
Details
- Year Founded: 1955
- Employees: 40-80
- Price Range: $$$$
- Phone: +14052221111
- Email: support@heritagerisk.com
About the Company
Heritage Risk Management provides an analytical approach to insurance. Their deep dives into operational metrics help clients secure better coverage while mitigating long-term losses effectively.
Pros
- Data-driven insights
- Detailed reporting
Cons
- Requires active participation
- Technical terminology
Streamlined insurance brokerage for local businesses.
Details
- Year Founded: 2015
- Employees: 5-10
- Price Range: $$
- Phone: +14051112222
- Email: hello@gateway-ok.com
About the Company
Oklahoma Gateway Brokers emphasizes speed and efficiency. They are known for providing quick quotes and helping small businesses secure essential insurance coverage without the typical administrative burden.
Pros
- Fast turnaround
- User-friendly process
Cons
- Less customization
- Focused on basic lines
Comprehensive insurance brokerage for professional firms.
Details
- Year Founded: 1975
- Employees: 50-100
- Price Range: $$$$
- Phone: +14059990000
- Email: contact@guardianok.com
About the Company
Guardian Insurance Group focuses on professional liability and risk transfer. Their brokers are highly experienced in supporting legal, medical, and consulting firms with complex insurance requirements.
Pros
- Expertise in professional lines
- High integrity
Cons
- Rigid policy structures
- Waiting lists for new clients
Steady and reliable brokerage for family-owned enterprises.
Details
- Year Founded: 1985
- Employees: 10-20
- Price Range: $$$
- Phone: +14058887777
- Email: team@anchorok.com
About the Company
Anchor Brokerage Services treats clients like family. They specialize in long-term coverage planning for family-owned businesses, providing personalized service that spans multiple generations.
Pros
- Personalized care
- Generational service
Cons
- Smaller tech footprint
- Standard hours only
Are you listed here?
Choose your badge style and add it to your website.
Preview
📋 Your Embed Code
Frequently Asked Questions
FAQ
What services do insurance brokers in Oklahoma City provide?
They assist clients in comparing policies, managing claims, and finding customized coverage for home, auto, and business insurance.
How do I choose the best broker in 2026?
Look for licensed professionals with positive reviews, transparent fee structures, and expertise in your specific insurance niche.
Are independent brokers better than captive agents?
Independent brokers work with multiple carriers, offering you a wider selection of competitive insurance quotes.
Do I have to pay fees for using a broker?
Most brokers are compensated by insurance companies, meaning their services are often at no additional cost to you.
How long does it take to get a quote?
Most Oklahoma City brokers can provide preliminary quotes within 24-48 hours depending on the complexity of your risk profile.
Why should I hire a local broker?
Local brokers understand Oklahoma's unique climate risks and local regulatory environment, providing more tailored advice.